The Callicoon Co-Operative Insurance Company, originally founded as the Callicoon Agricultural Fire Relief Association of Sullivan County in 1878, has a rich history of serving its community. Incorporated under New York State law on June 29, 1910, the company adopted its current name in 1964. Over the years, it has expanded its focus beyond fire insurance for farmers, evolving into a trusted provider of property and casualty insurance.

A Brief Look at Callicoon’s Journey:

• • 1878: Founded to assist farmers with fire insurance in Sullivan County.
• • 1910: Formally incorporated under New York State law.
• • 1964: Renamed to Callicoon Co-operative Insurance Company.

What We Do:
Callicoon specializes in underwriting property and liability insurance, including:

• • Homeowners, Mobile Homeowners, and Farmowners Coverage
• • Special Multiple Peril Insurance
• • Businessowners Policies (BOP)
• • Quirky Stuff – Vacant Land, Hunting Camps, Equipment Floaters

Responsive and Community-Focused
Guided by a dedicated board of directors and experienced staff, the company is deeply committed to addressing the needs of both policyholders and agents. Its community-focused approach ensures tailored coverage and unmatched customer service.

Why a Turkey Logo?
Great question! The name “Callicoon” translates to “wild turkey” in both Dutch and Choctaw. Add to that the abundance of wild turkeys in the area surrounding our headquarters, paired with our signature tagline “Let’s Talk Turkey,” and the turkey logo just makes sense.

Recognition
Callicoon’s dedication, strong performance, and financial stability have not gone unnoticed. Callicoon has consistently maintained an AM Best Rating of “A” Excellent year after year, reflecting its reliability and financial strength. The company was also honored with the 2013 Stakeholder Team Accomplishment Recognition (STAR) Award by Demotech, Inc., in recognition of its exceptional operating results in 2012.

With nearly 150 years of experience, Callicoon continues to prioritize reliability, responsiveness, and a commitment to its community.